Saturday, October 8, 2016

The Pin-tailed Wydah--Vidua macroura

The Pin-tailed Whydah is a bird that is seen regularly in Orange County. This one is a male. Photo from Wikicommons Photo by Stig Nygaard

Not too long ago an Orange County Birding post brought up an identification problem occurring in Orange County and other Southern California locations. People are reporting sightings of rare long-tailed flycatchers when in fact what they are seeing is the more common introduced species the Pin-tailed Whydah. It is actually not a flycatcher at all.

Female Pin-tailed Whydah from Wikicommons

The reason for the error is clear. Pin-tailed Whydahs are introduced birds that are not usually listed in the field guides. If a field guide is your only reference, then you are missing a key piece of information: Orange County and Southern California have large populations of introduced species from Asia, Africa, and several other locations. So remember that not all birds you observe may be in your field guide, and some may actually be introduced species. To avoid misidentifying this species as a rare flycatcher, you will need to become very familiar with the Pin-tailed Whydah.

Male Pin-tailed Whydah in Africa, from Wikicommons, photo uploaded by
New Jersey Birds



Pin-tailed Whydahs originated in Sub-Saharan Africa, but have been kept as a common cage bird in many countries. Pin-tailed Whydahs have escaped or been released in Singapore and The United States--in particular Southern California and the United States territory of Puerto Rico.  They have established significant breeding populations in Southern California. 

 From YouTube  Pin-tailed Whydah Chirping (California) by Kat Avila


Bill--The male Pin-tailed Whydah has a strong, bulky, bright orange bill built to crack seeds.  It is after all a finch. The brown, black, and white females are rather drab in comparison.  I have seen photographs that vary widely of in the color of the female's bill which I believe is due the nonbreeding male being identified as a female in some online photographs and vidoes.  


Pin-tailed Whydah from Wikicommons, photograph by Trisha Shears

Black Cap

The Pin-tailed Whydah had a black cap. The black cap of the Pin-tailed Whydah does not extend into the cheek area. So if the cheek is white and the cap is black, you most likely have a Pin-tailed Whydah.

Pin-tailed Whydah from Wiki Commons Derek Keats from Johannesburg, South Africa


The pin-tailed Whydah eats seeds, insects, and green plants. You will see the Pin-tailed Whydah perched or feeding on the ground or at a backyard feeder, but you will not see it fly catching.


Only breeding males have a long tail. Females and non breeding males have a normal-sized finch tail. 

The above video by 13seaeagle on YouTube shows the male and female Whydah, courtship behavior and more.  Notice the white cheek and the black cap on the male.  


Grasslands with bushes, trees, and water are the primary habitat. The Pin-tailed Whydah is also seen in cultivated gardens.  As you might imagine regional and other parks in Orange County are perfect habitats for the Pin-tailed Whydah.  Cemeteries in Orange County are also prime habitat.  There have been several sightings of Pin-tailed Whydahs--some in large groups-- at several Orange County cemeteries.  Pin-tailed Whydahs are regularly seen at Huntington Central Park, Craig Regional Park (first sighting in Orange County Birding was listed here in 2001), Carbon Canyon Regional Park,  Mile Square Regional Park, Yorba Linda Regional Park, Santa Ana River, Harriet Wieder Regional Park (not surprising since it is connected by open land to Huntington Central Park), backyard feeders in Yorba Linda, Westminster, and many other locations

Pin-tailed Whydah from Wiki Commons Derek Keats from Johannesburg, South Africa


Their breeding displays are impressive. The male hovers in front of the female displaying its long tail. Quite an attention grabber. The Pin-tailed Whydah is parasitic It usually lays its eggs in the waxbill's nest.  Some believe that in Orange County it is laying its eggs in the nests of another introduced alien species  the Scaly Breasted Munia aka Nutmeg Manikin aka Spice Finch. There is some concern that they may be using the nests of native birds.  Both male and female Pin-tailed Whydahs breed with several mates. They do not pair up to build a nest, brood, or raise their young since they lay their eggs in in the nests of other finch species.
Pin-tailed Whydah
Derek Keats from Johannesburg, South Africa


Pin-tailed Whydahs have been reported to chase other birds away at feeders and are generally aggressive. Males are even more aggressive when it is breeding seasonSince Pin-tailed Whydahs are finches, they will be seen around seed feeders, weeds and grasses laden with seeds. They are pretty much behave like other finches, but do it with a very long, black tail.


Very finch-like. High pitched calls.  Click on the links for  Xeno-Canto--Pin-tailed Whydah and for the Internet Bird Collection--Pin-tailed Whydah  to listen to actual recordings.

Other long-tailed Birds People Confuse with the Pin-tailed Whydah

1) The Fork-tailed Flycatcher Tyrannus savanna

Fork-tailed Flycatcher very, very rarely seen in Southern California 
Wikicommons Dario Sanches

Native to South America, Fork-tailed Flycatchers are not often seen in the United States. When they pop up, they create a quite a stir. Fork-tailed Flycatchers do have a black cap like the Pin-tailed Whydah. However, their posture and behavior are characteristic of kingbirds and flycatchers, not finches.  Note also that the black on the cap extends to the cheeks. The Pin-tailed Whydah's have white cheeks, not black. Fork-tailed Flycatchers will be seen flying out to catch insects, and also eating fruit in winter like kingbirdsThey forage close to the ground. (Sibley)

Fork-tailed Flycatcher--Wikicommons
Rogier Klappe

The Fork-tailed Flycatcher's bill is thin and black, and not at all not bulky or red like the Pin-tailed Whydah.  And note the gray on the upper back.  The Pin-tailed Whydah is black and white.   Fork-tailed Flycatchers are wanderers from the tropics of South America and are most often seen along the Atlantic coast, not the Pacific coast.  It would be amazingly rare to see one in Southern California.

Video by the Pantanal Bird Club promotes tours in the Brazilian pantanal and other important areas in South America.

2) The Scissor-tailed Flycatcher  Tyrannus forficatus

Scissor-tailed Flycatcher courtesy of the USFWS, photographer Robert Burton

Unlike the Fork-tailed Flycatcher Tyrannus savanna, the Scissor-tailed Flycatcher is actually a native of the United States.  In fact, the Scissor-tailed Flycatcher Tyrannus forficatus is the state bird of Oklahoma, and is also seen in Texas, and nearby states.  It is a native of Central America and migrates to Texas, Okalahoma, and nearby states in the summer to breedLike the Fork-tailed Flycatcher, the Scissor-tailed  Flycatcher is closely related to kingbirds being in the same genus,Tyrannus. It does tend to wander a bit during spring and fall migration and pop up in unusual places.

Scissor-tailed Flycatcher from the LabofOrnithology.

Notice how unlike the Pin-tailed Whydah it actually is. The colors are softer. The Scissor-tailed Flycatcher has gray and salmon colors as opposed to the cleanly patterned black and white of the Pin-tailed Whydah. The Scissor-tailed Flycatcher's cheeks are gray, not white. Note that Scissor-tailed Flycatcher DOES NOT have a black cap like the Pin-tailed Whydah and Scissor-tailed Flycatcher's bill is black and thin like a flycatcher rather than bulky and finch-like. The only thing they have in common with the Pin-tailed Whydah is that their tail is long.  However, even in that there are differences. The long tail of the Scissor-tailed Flycatcher has white in its tail unlike the all-black tail of the Pin-tailed Whydah. 

Juvenile Scissor-tailed Flycatcher (more white than the adult) courtesy of the USFWS, photographer Gary Kramer

You will see Scissor-tailed Flycatcher flying out often from low perches to catch insects like all kingbirds. They also will fly down and take insects from the ground or pick them off vegetation. Though, like kingbirds, you may see them perched near the ground, they are not eating seeds, but perched watching for insects.  In winter they expand their diet to include fruit. The sound and behavior of Scissor-tailed Flycatchers will definitely make you think, kingbird.

Field Observations

If you see a long-tailed bird that you think is rare, you must first check to eliminate the Pin-tailed Whydah.  

So ask yourself the following:

1) What color and shape is the bill?  A male Pin-tailed Whydah will have a bright orange, finch-like bill. 

2) What pattern and color does it have?  The Pin-tailed Whydah is cleanly marked with a black and white pattern.  

3) What color is the cheek?  If it is white, it is most likely a Pin-tailed Whydah.   

4) What kind of behavior does it exhibit?  Eating seeds foraging like a finch would exclude the rarer, long-tailed birds which are both flycatchers.  If it acts like a finch, it is most likely a Pin-tailed Whydah. 

Here is a very short video from YouTube by Nancy Balstad NMT.

When you report seeing a rare long-tailed flycatcher in Orange County, keep in mind that questions and requests for documentation are not personal. It is just good birding practice  For birding data to be meaningful, it must be as detailed and accurate as possible. This means questions will be asked and photographs or videos will be requested. It is not uncommon to see a Pin-tailed Whydah in Orange County, but it is very, very rare to see a Fork-tailed Flycatcher or a Scissor-tailed Flycatcher. Again, requests for documentation aren't  personal. We all make mistakes.  Remember, document, document, document. As they say in many professions, if it isn't documented, it didn't happen. 

Excellent video from 

Links and Resources

All About Birds--Scissor-tailed Flycatcher

Read about a rare bird often mistaken for the more common introduced Pin-tailed Whydah.

Audubon Guide to North American Birds--The Fork-tailed Flycatcher

Read more about another bird mistaken for the introduced Pin-tailed Whydah. 

Audubon Guide to North American Birds--The Scissor-tailed Flycatcher 
 Read about a rare bird often mistaken for the more common introduced Pin-tailed Whydah.

Internet Bird Collection--Pin-tailed Whydah

Very helpful site with pictures, videos, and sound recordings.   


Some good pictures. 

Xeno-Canto--Pin-tailed Whydah

Lots of sound bytes. 

Finch Information Center--Pin-tailed Whydah

Lots of information and pictures. 

Orange County Register--Unusual Bird Sighting

Article from 2013 regarding the Pin-tailed Whydah.

Check out my Facebook page.

Saturday, September 26, 2015

Carbon Canyon Regional Park

The lake at Carbon Canyon Regional Park.

Carbon Canyon Regional Park has a long history in Orange County.  Native Americans lived here long before Europeans came to Orange County.  The park and the adjacent Carbon Canyon Dam stand on the old site of the town of Olinda which was founded in the late 1800s.  Olinda eventually merged with the city of Randolph in 1911 to become the city of Brea which means tar or pitch in Spanish.  (Remember the La Brea Tar Pits?  Also named for the tar present in the ground.)  Oil later became a major industry in Olinda and later Brea.  After the oil was gone, citrus orchards became the major industry.  

One of two piers for fishing and viewing the lake.

Carbon Canyon Regional Park was established in 1965 after work on the dam was completed to prevent flooding.  The original park was 114 acres and has since expanded to 124 acres.  

Double-crested Cormorants resting and drying out after a swim.

Like many of Orange County's Regional Parks, it has a lake.   The lake was dredged and restored in 2014, and fishing is again allowed--with a license of course.  
There are sheltered picnic areas around the lake.

There are picnic tables around the lake and benches to sit and enjoy the view.  There are also barbecues and sheltered picnic areas as well.  The park has plenty of options for sports such as baseball fields, tennis and volleyball courts, horseshoe pits, and for the kids playgrounds.  There is an interpretive center and also interpretive programs.  The park has an amphitheater.  Near the amphitheater is a native and butterfly garden.  And there is an impressive 10-acre redwood grove that is great for birding.   There are bathrooms in many of the developed areas of the park. 

Another view of the lake.

Carbon Canyon Regional Park in Brea is a Regional Park with several different ecosystems that attract many species of birds.  It also benefits from being right next door to another rich birding stop, Chino Hills State Park. Chino Hills State Park is much closer to its natural state, and attracts lots of wildlife. Carbon Canyon Regional Park

American White Pelicans are often see in the lake fishing in fall and winter.

In fact, this section of Orange County has a wealth of great birding spots due to its being nestled against the Chino Hills in the north. The Chino Hills almost connects to Cleveland National Forest in the east so the north-east part of Orange County borders large, protected wildlife areas.
Scrub Jay near a parking lot.

Carbon Canyon Regional Park is also near Yorba Regional Park in Anaheim adjacent to Anaheim Hills which also has lots of great birding spots.  If you have the stamina, you can make it a birding day marathon of this area.  

Red-tailed Hawk soaring above the park.
Often, the first time I go to a birding area, I go with a group.  Because groups are often run by someone who knows the area, you often find a few secrets of the area such as spots off the main drag that hold rare or unusual birds.  And Carbon Canyon has several nature walks including one to their redwood forest which is led by park staff, and also occasional walks by Sea and Sage Audubon.  

In the fall the lawns are full of House Finches, Lesser Goldfinches, American Goldfinches, and Audubon Yellow-rumped Warblers to name a few. 

The Sea and Sage walks cover the main park, the redwood grove, and a walk into the back area by the dam.  Garett is a very knowledgeable birder and can be a fast walker when moving from one birding area to another.  (Garrett alternates Carbon Canyon with other Regional Parks in Orange County during the months he is not leading bird walks at Carbon Canyon Regional Park.)

One of the abundant Audubon Yellow-rumped Warblers in the park--known affectionately as "butter butts" by many birders.

You will find lots of birds on the lawns including Yellow-rumped Audubon Warblers aka butter butts, Lesser Goldfinches, American Goldfinches, and occasionally Horned Larks.  

Northern Flicker on the ground.  Not an unusual sight.

And occasionally, you may see Northern Flickers feeding on the lawn. There are also, I am sorry to say, lots of the invasive European Starlings.

California Ground Squirrel
And squirrels.

Scrub Jay comes down onto the ground to forage.
Scrub Jays are common in the less cultivated areas or on the edge of cultivated and wilder areas.

A Black Phoebe.  In Orange County, there is always a Black Phoebe.

The park has two phoebes: Black Phoebes and

Say's Phoebe visit in fall and winter.

Say's Phoebes. The Black Phoebe is the year-round resident.  Black Phoebes are found everywhere in Orange County.  Every home has at least one, and parks have several. 

Acorn Woodpecker--male.
Acorn Woodpeckers are year-round residents of the park.  

Acorn Woodpecker

If you go to Carbon Canyon Regional Park, you definitely will see them.  

Female--black band between red cap and white forehead.

Acorn Woodpeckers are in the east side of the lake for the most part.  They are sometimes loud, but not always obvious when quiet.  

Acorn Woodpeckers two males (left) and female (right).

Although the main part of their diet is acorns, they are often on trees that are not oaks In this park.

The fall colors as we headed out to the dam were just beautiful.

It is a long walk out to the dam and back with plenty to see along the way including raptors.

Expect a lot of dusty dirt paths.

The walk out to the dam is definitely work the effort.

Gorgeous textures and colors.

Getting back to the main park area.  It is lower than much of the surrounding land and bordered on several sides by hill over which you can often see raptors like Red-tailed Hawks soaring over the hills or perched in the trees on the hills.  Also seen in this area, Cooper's Hawks, and American Kestrels.

Turkey Vulture

I like to sit and enjoy the park after hiking.  

This particular day, I observed a small drama with a pair of Egyptian geese and their goslings on the lake's shore.   They started walking down the pier with their 5 goslings.

Egyptian Geese with goslings walk down the pier.

Watch below as the goslings try to get the nerve to follow their parents into the water.

Safe on shore at last.

Egyptian Goose

Carbon Canyon Regional Park is a great place to go birding.  I love to stop by at several of the birding hot spots out in this area.  It is adjacent to Chino Hills State Park.  And not far from Carbon Canyon Regional Park also in Brea is Craig Regional Park just west of the 57 freeway.  Last time I went, I stopped at Carbon Canyon Regional Park, stopped at Wildbirds Unlimited in Yorba Linda (awesome feeding station and store), then Yorba Regional Park, Oak Canyon Nature Center, and finally Irvine Regional Park.  Mix and match and create your own birdathon.

It is a beautiful park.

Wherever you go, have fun birding in Orange County.

OC Birder Girl Links

Acorn Woodpecker

American Kestrel

American White Pelicans

Black Phoebe

Double-Crested Cormorants

Northern Flicker

Red-tailed Hawk

Say's Phoebe

Turkey Vultures


Carbon Canyon Regional Park

Orange County Regional Park link.